Roger Kwok Chun On, Christine Ng Wing Mei, Annie Man Chung Han, Wayne Lai Yiu Cheung, Gilbert Lam Wai Sun, Cheung Wai Yee, Edmund So Chi Wai, Lo Koon Lan, Halina Tam Siu Wan, Lo Hoi PangWhat, when, where and whoI am not sure how to write this review without telling you the storyline, because if I tell you the storyline, you will blaming me for telling you too much... but if I don't tell you anything, this page will be empty. Oh well... here is the big picture of the story: the story is like a big puzzle, which involves the death of Roger's father, and the murder who planned the whole set. There are many little cases, and there are lots of suspects, which link one another, and making the big puzzle more and more clear, until the puzzle finally got solved by Roger, Christine (Roger's girlfriend) and Annie. The relationships in this series are pretty interesting and complicated, but I can't tell you too much, the only things I can tell you is that, Roger and Christine are lovers, Annie has crush on Roger, and so is Halina, but who turned out to be really crazy...THE FACTORS- Dislike FactorChristine NgI really like this series because of the storyline and Roger Kwok, but I will really love this series if they use someone else instead of Christine. The major reason is that Christine just can't act in this series, I especially don't like the way she screams... I am just so not use to the way she acts, makes me feel that she is trying too much, but she couldn't do anything.- Love FactorRoger KwokRoger delivers very amazing performances in this series, especially the crying scenes, felt so touching and memorable. I loved his character as well, who has a very tough background, and the fact that he is supposedly "designed" (a tool) for the murder puzzle. His real identity has a very interesting twist, and makes his relationship with the others changed dramatically.Annie ManI love to see her and Roger together a lot more than watching Roger and Christine together. Annie and Roger always together solving puzzles, I just love the way they communicate with each other. Annie's hearing and speaking skills are not as normal as regular persons, she sometimes communicate with Roger with sign language, and Roger always takes care of her and helping her go through many difficulties, which makes Annie has serious crush on Roger...The storylineThis entire series is just about one case, however, there are many links to the result of the case, which makes the entire storyline so interesting, and you just dying to know the result, so, this is the type of series that you will finish watching in just 2-3 days. There are lots of suspects, some of them are innocent, some of them are not. We might not realized who is really guilty, even though we do, it still takes time to figure out why and how they did it. Also, when we thought some case is over, but it is not, there is always someone else behind the whole thing, or someone else related to the whole thing. I think the English title "Greed Mask" fits this series perfectly, good title, hmm.. I wonder who named that English title...- How Come FactorWayne Lai VS Halina TamYou will not have a single clue about what I am saying in this paragraph if you did not finish watching Greed Mask, or at least till the end of episode 19 (yuck, the end of episode 19 totally creeps me out). So, skip this part if you want to... Anyways, I guess what I am trying to say here is that, I don't like the true identity of Wayne, because it really creeps me out, and hate the way he speaks in episode 20. I agree that Wayne and Halina are important keys in the story, because without him or her, this series just feel different, because I loved the part where Wayne lost his memory, and tries to find out who he really is, this is a very special twist in the storyline, and just totally makes sense, and totally shocking. However, the makeover just totally unbelievable! I don't think there is some technology that is so advanced, and can make someone looks so different! I guess you will feel pity for Halina, who took revenge in a totally different way, and totally creepy way... this is scary...Best Scenes1. Roger and Annie together solving cases, they are pretty good partners... Both of them are really smart, and together they are making good chemistry, even though they are not lovers2. Roger and his mother reunion, o my god, that tears coming out from Roger's eyes, makes me heart break!3. When Wayne reveals the true identity to Roger, and how he planned the revenge. It is creepy, but it is a good scene when Wayne felt from the building, and Roger wants to save him, but it was too late... pretty emotional4. All the creepy moments, which makes you want to watch what happen next, and making you feeling surprise about the way the series is made.... and the sequences of the storyline...THE COMMENTS- The PerformancesAll the true suspects are the most amazing factors in this series, because they all "wearing masks", you can not tell that they are the suspects because they pretend to be the nice ones. I think those people deliver very good performances, and making the audiences believe in them, then suspect them, then realized they are bad. Pretty much every single character is a suspect in this series, except Roger, his performances are very memorable... The only one screw up is Christine, as I told you, without her this series will be perfect, at least 95% perfect- The StorylineThe storyline is almost perfect, I just think they need to work on the Wayne VS Halina part, that part is a little bit unbelievable, but I am not sure how they can rework that part if they have to. But, other than that, the story is really great, so interesting and everything just link each other perfectly.- Worth Watching?This series is very interesting, because you are trying to figure out who is the murder all the time, but even if you kind of know, you still have no idea why and how they did it, and also how they related to the entire story. You just need to keep watching and watching until you finally find out the result... Sometimes, the storyline really creeps you out, hmm.. don't watch it at night...
忽略伍姑娘的年纪,还是很喜欢两个人还是兄妹的时候那种暧昧。
那种乱伦的快感,一下子让我可以接受兄妹恋。
很花痴安仔演的哥哥,大少爷,认真工作,孝顺,对女友专情,对家人不吝啬给予温暖。
这样的二世祖,真的是比恐龙还稀有。
一个完完全全可以依赖的男人,又年轻帅气和善,即使是做妹妹的,真的很难不动心。
昨天看到第18集,一直耿耿于怀这部豆瓣打分不上八 本来打算给五星拉高得分的,今天看完之后...四星半好了∠( ᐛ 」∠)_好看是真好看 半星扣在真实性方面—————//剧透分界//————我还是挺吃男女主官配CP的...!
就是这俩人不会好好沟通真要命,不过一部分原因也是人物关系太复杂导致吧~峰认返云姐之后 他和彤彤真的好多事都瞒住珊呀,也不能怪她有点儿急躁 乱猜测吧。
佩佩出现之后峰就完全OOC了,居然说出“虽然她是用计谋靠近我 我们还是有过感情”“结婚了也能继续照顾你”这种屁话?!
她骗你感情骗你钱、出轨你姑父、要杀你骗保险金都没让你放低她???
实在觉得彤彤和峰没有CP感...当妹妹二十多年看大的,怎么可能身世不同之后转变成爱情嘛!
彤彤就是性格内向没接触太多人而已。
但是想拆峰珊不是也耍了些手段?
而且真搞不懂她干嘛弄一个佩佩声音模拟器...查她 不用模拟她吧?
后面也没解释~这模拟器任谁见到都会觉得彤装神弄鬼实锤感觉全剧最好看的几集是珊不断发噩梦,然后发现梦中意向正是别墅走廊、镜中人竟然是自己,以及后面梦到凶器位置并验证那段,鸡皮疙瘩掉一地啊~~最高超的暗线就是欧文伟一出现就懂化妆以及他引荐重要人物风水先生。
可是毁容了整容就行啊为啥费大劲变性?
而且恢复还挺快 还保留两个声线;最后两集峰珊电话就是打不通 联系不上;彤彤最后所谓的醒悟 峰珊的心有灵犀完全瞎说(觉得他来过 没走 大概率只是沙发还有他的体温 什么心有灵犀啊扯)这些点让我扣最终决定扣半星佩佩也别搞什么痴情人设了 是男是女都是骗钱第一要务啊喂!
女声黎耀祥演的好好但也太容易笑场了哈哈哈哈哈哈哈又惊悚又想笑 尤其转圈圈那里以前总觉得安仔是搞笑担当那种,意外通过这部剧get到他的颜了呀!!
他讲粤语有点点慢条斯理,萌~而且有些角度神态又好似张国荣...不愧是拿过几次视帝的男人 爱了~
本观后感有剧透,建议没看这部剧的人别点开这剧评。
TVB的谜情家族,算是一部少有的悬疑家族剧。
而且这部剧,能够做到悬疑十足,引人入胜,真是TVB难得的佳作。
其实全剧的主要核心就是高卓文家族的财产,各种形形色色的反派围绕财产而引发一系列的悬疑事件。
1. 乐佩佩装疯事件。
全剧开篇是男主角高峰的女友乐佩佩为了高家财产,特意引用林敏事件来装疯扮傻,企图利用精神病杀人无罪这个点来谋杀高峰,以未婚妻(或者是太太)的身份来骗取财产。
幸得高峰的机智以及司徒珊的介入,乐佩佩阴谋败露,在逃亡过程中不慎堕海身亡。
事件暂时告一段落。
这个案子很好奠定了本剧的诡异风格,这种神秘诡异的氛围一直延续到全剧结束。
2.高卓文被杀事件经历过乐佩佩事件之后,司徒珊得到高卓文的特别照顾,再加上司徒珊的舅舅司徒柏年无意间透露了自己的过去经历,引起高峰对高卓文的过去经历的强烈好奇心。
结果导致了两父子关系非常恶劣。
不久,高卓文被杀,高峰以及司徒珊一起调查高家相关人员,后来因表妹彤彤被牵扯到案情而被法庭控告,令调查一度陷入瓶颈,后来在司徒珊新认识的朋友欧文伟帮助下,认识了一名催眠大师,从而找到了真正的杀人凶手——张汉明(Willson),并将他绳之于法,最后因袭击高峰及司徒珊,被警察射杀身亡。
这个事件算是本剧中最精彩的段落,把高家每一个人的性格都描绘得淋漓尽致,每个人都各怀鬼胎,勾心斗角,互相算计,直至真凶落网,都非常精彩。
在这期间还揭露了司徒珊与高卓文的父女关系,还有司徒珊舅舅与高卓文的过去经历,高卓文身上伤口的存疑,都为后来的事件一一埋下了伏笔。
3.高峰、司徒珊身世之谜高卓文的遗嘱公开,高峰被司徒珊代替成为遗产继承人,随后出现了高家闹鬼事件,令高峰怀疑管家云姐的动机,从而引出了高峰身世之谜。
接下来的剧情就重点围绕司徒珊继承遗产所发生的各种事情,在17-18集引出本剧第二个高潮——司徒柏年真面目被揭开,解开了他与高卓文、高峰的亲生父亲李杰三十年的恩恩怨怨,利用司徒珊、高峰等人的亲子关系作各种文章、并在高卓文重伤之下给了致命一刀使其彻底死去,算是本剧中比较老谋深算的反派。
同时这段剧情也彻底解释了高峰及司徒珊的身世来历。
期间还穿插了欧文伟中枪失忆、司徒珊、高峰共同追查欧文伟的过去经历,为后来的剧情做铺垫。
个人觉得这段剧情开始,本剧的结构就开始松散起来,由于穿插的各人经历太多,没有之前高卓文被杀事件那么紧凑。
4.欧文伟身世之谜高峰及司徒珊即将结婚,高峰却收到本已死去的女友乐佩佩的短信,两人再度争执。
欧文伟在两人间来回周旋,表面为两人缓和关系,实际上却挑拨两人关系,令关系进一步恶化。
最终揭开了欧文伟真正的身份——变成变性人的乐佩佩。
这一事件,篇幅占的比例较短,但实际上在欧文伟出场的集数开始,就已经有很多细节可以挖掘。
例如欧文伟对女性护肤品的了解、以及对催眠大师的认识等等都可以看出欧文伟并不是简单的角色。
很多时候,他的出现就是剧情的主要推动者。
例如,介绍高峰催眠大师,让他了解张汉明与他的师生关系;在医院里故意刺激张汉明,使他情绪失控被警察射杀;还有与司徒珊合作,利用假绑架事件使司徒柏年露出马脚等等。
他所做的这一切都是为了谋夺高家财产,比起张汉明及司徒柏年,真是有过之而无不及。
而且最后之所以失败,是因为自己还深爱高峰,从而放弃遗产。
还有就是太过自负,留下了日记让彤彤了解了她的阴谋。
除这一两个失误,她所做的一切都是工于心计,不愧是全剧最大、最出人意料的反派。
这部剧算是TVB少有的以一个核心事件贯穿全剧的悬疑剧。
而且还算合情合理。
乐佩佩、张汉明、司徒柏年、欧文伟,各个反派的出色表演都增添了不少的看点。
但并不代表它毫无缺点。
例如,相对于反派角色塑造的出彩及惊艳程度,男女主角的塑造只能算中规中矩,而且他们动不动就怀疑别人,动不动就各种吵架,就连最后的司徒珊对高峰的所谓心灵感应(最后一集高峰从天台扔照片吸引司徒珊注意)都略显生硬,CP感塑造的有点不好。
还有最后一集欧文伟身世揭秘那一刻,虽然是很劲爆,但是还是有点不可思议,样子变了没问题,但是连声音都彻底变成男性的,略夸张了些。
不过黎耀祥的表演确实非常出色,值得一赞。
总而言之,这部剧算是看点十足,是我喜欢的TVB十大电视剧之一,值得一看。
一开始看的时候就知道了黎耀祥的佩佩,这种偏执的爱真的令人唏嘘。
前面几集就是他们家里的一些事,从峰的女朋友,到珊的身世,再到高老爸的故事。
从别人口中听到的过去,未必是真的过去,这便为后面的反转提供的后路。
奶妈原来是亲妈,这符合一般套路。
高老爸花心加出轨。
司徒老舅“误杀”李杰,高老爸帮忙隐瞒外加收藏骨灰,最后还对老舅那么好…我???
总感觉后面接不上。
我最喜欢催眠那一段,特别是从电梯开始全是假的,表妹死了我都惊了,她不是女二嘛?
结果一反转,妙极了!
(实习天使也有这个套路,不愧是tvb)然后说到黎耀祥出场,我就一直暗搓搓地期待,还和我妈剧透“这个是乐佩佩!
”,结果他失忆了…我???
她们去到大屿山(果然最远只能到大屿山和南丫岛)找过去。
那个傻子看见阿伟就害怕,跟见鬼了一样。
我懂了,awsl,啊,我死了,阿伟死了。
那傻子见到阿伟死了。
果然,我对了,awsl。
这部剧基本上都挺好的,除了感情戏和女主无槽点。
其实我是站骨科表哥表妹可,虽然知道剧情不会是这样,但是真的能够跟上点,有默契有经历有感情,表哥特意学手语沟通,各种安慰表妹(虽然是因为内疚),兄控什么的真的很戳我,而且他们又不是亲生的。
唉,青梅也打不过天降。
特别是天上掉下来的一张结婚照…尴尬得不行,就像节目组告诉你这里有证据一样莫名其妙。
男女主没有cp感,我和我妈一致认为他们是姐弟,不像兄妹。
还不如看双三帝有意思呢,两个拿过两个视帝的男人!
最后吐槽一下女主,人设实在太糟糕了,不停的崩坏。
开始当秘书的时候,没有一丝看起来像一个专业的秘书,上台主持的时候完全是???
就像是潜规则上位的,然后后面高老爸说她工作没有任何差错。
我???
槽点太多不知从何说起。
后面代理行政总裁,刚接任开会时,突然变成了一个精英,就看不到一丝紧张和压迫,就一脸天下劳资最大的样子,与后文被逼接任完全不一样,我现在说不上来,但是追剧的时候真的觉得她好烦。
还是表白郭晋安黎耀祥文颂娴吧,还有司徒伯年(霍景良果然是坏人)最后表白编剧导演,真厉害love&peace !
悬念铺排不错,揭密当然有些狗血,哪里能变性又整容的?
不过,一个心怀复仇大计的人半途遭遇不测,中途失忆会怎么样?
如果按照这样的线索下去,可以是不错的电影。
这剧的TVB编剧,想作出一次尝试,可能是观众水平不高吧,又或者确实风格另类了点,所以收视不高,但绝对是好剧,值得一看
小时候看过,现在又回顾了一遍,发现bug还是挺多的……故事设定很出彩,一环接一环的,也基本在一条线上,除了有头尾呼应外,其中的一些作案桥段都很新颖,蛮妙的。
就是部分剧情的衔接部分在处理上还不够细致。
角色设定的话,看到最后竟然意外的不喜欢男女主角【哭笑不得】,大概觉得他们俩太双标了,很合适在一起了;郭晋安也意外让我觉得有点烦了,这个人设在我看来不好呀~伍咏薇这个女主在演绎上都差强人意,不中意啊~表妹周依彤这个角色,听力弱会手语会读唇语电脑技术好,技术上很厉害了~文颂娴扮演的很招人喜欢了~黎耀祥在这个剧里面真的蛮出彩的,角色有反差,还演的很自然,很棒!
看了很多TVB的剧,本剧“谜情家族”设置的悬念环环相扣,凶手反转再反转①三十年前三结拜兄弟谁杀了李杰②高BOSS死于谁手(自闭女☞心理男☞司徒)真凶最后露出,下巴掉下来!
③佩变伟,女变性成男,颠覆三观,猜不透总的来说这部剧编的很好,节奏快,TVB最佳悬疑片,非常值得一看,五星推荐!
常言道听来的不是真实的,只有亲眼见到的才是真的。
但是《谜情家族》告诉我们一个道理:看到的也未必是真实的。
整部剧虽然一开始觉得是一个案子跟着一个案子,有点像《刑事侦缉档案》但是看到中间的时候会发现所有的案件其实都是串联在一起的,这样的悬疑片才最让人期待的。
有很多人不喜欢女主角伍咏薇,不过我觉得挺好啊,只不过年纪稍大了点呵呵,换成蔡少芬如何?
相当精彩的一部悬疑剧。竟然只有7.3分?
挺灵的
第一感觉很惊悚~~不过不错啦
其实剧情还是不错的,就是女主不讨喜,里面有个案子是抄袭了W的两个悲剧,实在太像了,没想到tvb的编剧这么早就开始抄日本推理小说
天呐,全家基本没有正常人,郭晋安和伍咏薇也不搭呀
凑合
挺好看的
这个剧……真的……是我第一次看到男女主一丁点CP感都没有的戏
我看得都快吓死了- -
前幾年重溫過,好看!就是現在很多片子一點也比不了!
围绕一个家族的多个谜团案件,环环相扣一层推一层,虽然把催眠用得也未免太飘了,但依然可以说做得很不错了。伍咏薇同郭晋安非常没有火花,倒是文颂娴依然超可爱。
所以说...w的悲剧只是其中一个故事么哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈
正统本格在TVB(大笑)就为了那几条暗线写的单元剧本,除了有一些时间上的出入没做好、小细节处理得过于强行外,整体还不错。但我还是比较期待最后着力点不要是吵着说爱不爱我,以及男女主至少黑化一个。
我的青少年阴影,晚上都得我妈陪着才敢看这部剧。这里面的案情都好精彩哦
剧情真是山路十八弯啊。
虽然是小时候看的但是竟然对剧情也印象很深,真的很好看,喜欢郭晋安,喜欢文颂娴。
x
就是w的悲剧。
谁说好看的……赤裸裸地抄袭W的悲剧的手法……这种片子只适合平时很少看侦探小说的家伙。
我靠,太狗血了!本来冲着郭晋安看的,结果女主角给配的像郭他妈!剧情像《知音》杂志的内容……